http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/books/2012/07/02/120702crbo_books_kolbert
I had two friends post this article on thier Facebook pages today and I read it as soon as I could this morning. Very interesting! Not really something I didn't think already...because I tend to harbor the idea or theory that if you involve children they will learn much quicker. This is for sure the Montessori method of giving the child the opporutinity to do somehting on their own and then showing them how do it. I think the Waldorf exposure will give them a bit of this too, but instead from a different perspective, one of seeing things from beginning to end. An example is the sheep. They will care for the sheep, shear the sheep, spin the wool, dye the wool, knit the wool, etc to a finished product at the Waldorf school. This article seems to highlight these truths and cirsumstances.
However, I have to say the comparisons of the two cultures, that of the Peruvian Amazon and those who habitat in Los Angeles, CA are in such stark contrast that it is difficult to compare. Here in the US we have so many different "opporutinites" given to us, survival is not necessaruly our first course of action for the day. Whereas the tribe spent thier observed time "camping," gathering leaves to build homes and fishing for the food they ate. The lifestyles are extremely different.
I agree that in our lifestyle we need to step back and take on some primitve methods when it comes to raising our children. We seem to be in such a rush to get things done, to go places or devour more knowldge that we have forgotten to take a breath, and realize that our children are just that, children and take a bit longer to do things than our lifestyle sometimes allows. The little girl in the article had all day to gather the crustations, sweep the mats, etc. I've observed parents and sometimes find myslef rushing the girls out the door to get somewhere "on time." I am guitly of it, but try so hard not not allow myself to do this to the girls.
Knowing this makes me so glad I have choosen to be a SAHM for them. Most of the time, we have time to explain, teach and observe our girls so they can do things for themselves to get out the door. Be it getting dressed, putting on thier shoes, brushing htier teeth, etc. I allow them the time to do these things for themselves because it is important for self esteem and survival for them to be able to do this.
With all that said, as much as I want the girls to be self suffiencent and to learn to care for themselves, they are still my babies! I love to take care of them, do things for them, surprise them with love and trinkets. We are at a point in time in our society where children are cherished not thought of as work hands. I am grateful to live in this time period in the US. I see childhood as something that doesn't last long and they should enjoy it. I think that is a perk of our society, one where you actually do get to be a child when you are one. I want to make thier childhood full of memories, fun times, experiences, and knowledge to help enrich thier adult lives. So I do, do things for them that they could do for themselves. Such as combing thier hair and putting it in cute ponytails or making thier meals (I do enlist thier help, but I haven't made them master the tasks yet).
With all of that said, this article did make me think and gave me something fun to ponder for the day. I enjoy Facebook to see posts like this. We all have our own opinions, this is a sparkle of mine on the subject.